Well, Kris has lodged an appeal so, Apad, your up.
Animefan666 (me): One day I'd like to wipe out humanity...and maybe conquer the city. Ya know, the usual.
Then, once everyone is a zombie, we all starve and Serling dies. A perfect end to a doomed city.
Zombie61: /Rename Animefan666 to The-Brain.
Animefan666: So, now that we've established that I am Brain, who will be my not so brainy sidekick Pinky?
Kris: You suddenly remind me of Magneto's White House Speech in Days of Future Past.
TAC: So who's gonna be my right hand mutant?
Fortunado: And now i need something to restore my faith in humanity... been a struggle to stop losing it.
LeSageStupide: Have you ever just stared at TAC's avatar for a while? It helps a lot.
In hindsight we were damned either way. If we'd said nothing we'd have been criticised for going against a decision of the Assembly to create a LC open to all and now by exercising our function to recommend the Assembly sort it all out, we have an appeal from the other side. :facepalm:
At this point, I don't care if the entire ruling is undone. If Kris wants to make this unnecessarily difficult, that's his problem.
Animefan666 (me): One day I'd like to wipe out humanity...and maybe conquer the city. Ya know, the usual.
Then, once everyone is a zombie, we all starve and Serling dies. A perfect end to a doomed city.
Zombie61: /Rename Animefan666 to The-Brain.
Animefan666: So, now that we've established that I am Brain, who will be my not so brainy sidekick Pinky?
Kris: You suddenly remind me of Magneto's White House Speech in Days of Future Past.
TAC: So who's gonna be my right hand mutant?
Fortunado: And now i need something to restore my faith in humanity... been a struggle to stop losing it.
LeSageStupide: Have you ever just stared at TAC's avatar for a while? It helps a lot.
Im not seeing what the issue is here. We made a recomendation as to how the assembly can bring the lc into legality if its original intent was to make the position open to everyone.
Apad
King of Haldilwe
The decision is yours, as set out by The Charter.
Animefan666 (me): One day I'd like to wipe out humanity...and maybe conquer the city. Ya know, the usual.
Then, once everyone is a zombie, we all starve and Serling dies. A perfect end to a doomed city.
Zombie61: /Rename Animefan666 to The-Brain.
Animefan666: So, now that we've established that I am Brain, who will be my not so brainy sidekick Pinky?
Kris: You suddenly remind me of Magneto's White House Speech in Days of Future Past.
TAC: So who's gonna be my right hand mutant?
Fortunado: And now i need something to restore my faith in humanity... been a struggle to stop losing it.
LeSageStupide: Have you ever just stared at TAC's avatar for a while? It helps a lot.
You know TAC I think in the future you should decide ahead of time who the non presiding justice is going to be on a particular case. Seeing as I had to issue a ruling on an appeal for a majority opinion I helped to write made it difficult for me to come up with a ruling. This is not meant as a knock on your tenure as Cheif I just think in order to be completely impartial the non presiding justice should not be involved in discussions of the case he/she might have to make a ruling on appeal.
What do you think?
Apad
King of Haldilwe
I've been going on a first come first serve basis. Once the first three Justices that got in on it agree, that's it, I post it, which is why you were put on as the non-presiding justice.
Animefan666 (me): One day I'd like to wipe out humanity...and maybe conquer the city. Ya know, the usual.
Then, once everyone is a zombie, we all starve and Serling dies. A perfect end to a doomed city.
Zombie61: /Rename Animefan666 to The-Brain.
Animefan666: So, now that we've established that I am Brain, who will be my not so brainy sidekick Pinky?
Kris: You suddenly remind me of Magneto's White House Speech in Days of Future Past.
TAC: So who's gonna be my right hand mutant?
Fortunado: And now i need something to restore my faith in humanity... been a struggle to stop losing it.
LeSageStupide: Have you ever just stared at TAC's avatar for a while? It helps a lot.
(07-30-2015, 11:42 PM)Kris Kringle Wrote: I formally request that all threads related to the discussion of the original and appeal rulings be released to the public.
Since the Sunshine Provision only includes the Cabinet, it's entirely up to us. We should decide this collectively. I don't care either way though.
Animefan666 (me): One day I'd like to wipe out humanity...and maybe conquer the city. Ya know, the usual.
Then, once everyone is a zombie, we all starve and Serling dies. A perfect end to a doomed city.
Zombie61: /Rename Animefan666 to The-Brain.
Animefan666: So, now that we've established that I am Brain, who will be my not so brainy sidekick Pinky?
Kris: You suddenly remind me of Magneto's White House Speech in Days of Future Past.
TAC: So who's gonna be my right hand mutant?
Fortunado: And now i need something to restore my faith in humanity... been a struggle to stop losing it.
LeSageStupide: Have you ever just stared at TAC's avatar for a while? It helps a lot.
Im not entirely sure what Kris hopes to achieve with this request. Seems to be a witch hunt or gotcha politics. He wants the judiciary to be independent but wants the transcripts to its discussions when a ruling goes against his opinions.
Apad
King of Haldilwe
I'm against releasing this thread. It sets a bad precedent.
|
![[+]](/images/collapse_collapsed.png "[+]")
I am a Super Villain
