Repeal "Condemn Stujenske"
A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.
 
Category: Repeal
Resolution: SC#174
Proposed by: Coupy

Description: WA Security Council Resolution #174: Condemn Stujenske shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Argument: The Security Council,

Acknowledging that the original resolution to condemn The Gone Fishin of Stujenske was intended to raise awareness in the World Assembly about the coup d'etat in Lazarus happening at that time;

Noting, however, that the coup executed by the New Pacific Order was short-lived due to the efforts of Kazmr and that the Humane Republic of Lazarus continues to flourish under the leadership of Loftegen;

Further noting that the decision to coup Lazarus was made under a state of impaired judgement, leading many to believe that the following actions were never meant to be serious;

Affirming that Stujenske's participation in the aforementioned coup ofLazarus, largely orchestrated by Milograd, was very limited and that bothStujenske and Stujenske's actions remain irrelevant to the wider community and unworthy of a condemnation;

Recognizing the probability that Stujenske views the condemnation symbol as a "badge of honor", despite the fact that this nation did absolutely nothing to earn it;

Hereby repeals Security Council Resolution #174: Condemn Stujenske.

(This post was last modified: 02-20-2016, 07:38 PM by Railana.)

Reply

I'm inclined to support a vote AGAINST this repeal. Stujenske couped Lazarus and tried to make it a colony of the NPO against the will of Lazarene natives. I think that's worthy of a condemnation.

A few points addressing the arguments made in the resolution:

• The "impaired judgement" excuse is absurd. We don't excuse vehicular homicide when committed by drunk drivers.
  
• I don't know too much about who else was involved in the coup, but even if the player behind Stujenske wasn't the mastermind behind it, it still makes sense that the condemnation goes to the nation of Stujenske because it was ultimately that nation that did the couping.
  
• I don't really subscribe to the "condemnation as reward" theory; condemnations should be viewed in the IC sense of the World Assembly condemning immoral behaviour, and what Stujenske tried to do was certainly wrong.
  

(This post was last modified: 02-16-2016, 01:50 PM by Railana.)

Reply

"Repeal "Condemn Stujenske"" was defeated 12,316 votes to 2,133.

Reply