I think whether this proposal becomes a reasonable way to make things more streamlined or an extension of oligarchy largely depends not on the actual law, but on how it is socially interpreted. If the DC is seen as closer to being like the Assembly than like the current CRS on the scale of exclusiveness, we're good. If, though, it retains the perception of exclusiveness at the level of the current CRS, this proposal will turn into nothing short of self-regenerating oligarchy.