Punchwood
RON

Reply

Punchwood
Re-Open Nominations

Reply

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Re-Open Nominations
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Punchwood

Reply

Punchwood
Cathalea
RON

Reply

I would like to point out the lack of my own name in multiple ballots, namely those of Omega, fmastr, Marcus IV, and Wolf, with Wolf also not listing Punchwood. Due to the end of the voting period in two minutes, I request that the vote be counted with these ballots not counted as a part of the final tally.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

ProfessorHenn
Legislator

(This post was last modified: 02-21-2016, 02:59 PM by ProfessorHenn.)

Reply

Voting is Closed.

[Image: HuoZhaoDao.png]

Reply

In random order, styled in my example style (changing "and" to "&" and abbreviations to full names), the following votes for Minister of Regional Affairs were received privately:

1. Punchwood
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

1. Punchwood
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

1. Cathalea
2. Punchwood
3. Re-Open Nominations
3. Zak6858

1. Cathalea
2. Punchwood
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

1. Zak6858
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Punchwood
3. Cathalea

1. Punchwood
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Cathalea
4. Zak6858

1. Punchwood
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

[Image: HuoZhaoDao.png]

Reply

Counting

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Re-open Nominations
2. Punchwood
3. Cathalea
4. Zak6858

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	0	0	0
Punchwood	1	-	1	0
Cathalea	1	0	-	0
Re-Open Nominations	1	1	1	-

Cathalea
Punchwood
Zak6858
Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	0	0	1
Punchwood	2	-	1	1
Cathalea	2	1	-	1
Re-Open Nominations	1	1	1	-

Cathalea
Punchwood
Re Open Nominations
Zadiner/Zak6858


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	0	0	1
Punchwood	3	-	1	2
Cathalea	3	2	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	2	1	1	-

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Re-open Nominations
2. Zak6858
3. Punchwood
4. Cathalea

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	1	1	1
Punchwood	3	-	2	2
Cathalea	3	2	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	3	2	2	-

Re-open Nominations
Punchwood
Cathalea
Zak6858

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	1	1	1
Punchwood	4	-	3	2
Cathalea	4	2	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	4	3	3	-

Punchwood
Zak6858
Re-Open Nominations
Cathalea

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	1	2	2
Punchwood	5	-	4	3
Cathalea	4	2	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	4	3	4	-

RON
Cathalea
Zak6858
Punchwood

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	2	2
Punchwood	5	-	4	3
Cathalea	5	3	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	5	4	5	-

RoN
Punchwood
Cathalea

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	2	2
Punchwood	6	-	5	3
Cathalea	6	3	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	6	5	6	-

Punchwood
RON
Cathalea
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Zak has dropped out of the race so he can not be on the ballot.

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	2	2
Punchwood	7	-	6	4
Cathalea	7	3	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	7	5	7	-

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Punchwood
2. Zak6858
3. RoN
4. Cathalea

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	3	3
Punchwood	8	-	7	5
Cathalea	7	3	-	2
Re-Open Nominations	7	5	8	-

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Punchwood
2. Zak6858
3. Cathalea
3. Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	4	4
Punchwood	9	-	8	6
Cathalea	7	3	-	3
Re-Open Nominations	7	5	8	-

Cathalea
Punchwood
Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	4	4
Punchwood	10	-	8	7
Cathalea	8	4	-	4
Re-Open Nominations	8	5	8	-

Punchwood
Cathalea
Zak6858
RON

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	4	5
Punchwood	11	-	9	8
Cathalea	9	4	-	5
Re-Open Nominations	8	5	8	-

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Punchwood
2. RoN
3.Cathalea
4. Re-Open Nominations

This ballot cannot be counted as it is ambiguous as to how it ranks Re-Open Nominations.

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Most Preferred Option: Punchwood
2. Less Preferred Option: RON

This ballot is questionable. It does not explicitly list all options. The only way to interpret it unambiguously is if one assumes that Zak6858 is an invalid option due to their posted withdrawal from the race (and that the omitted option, Cathalea, is ranked last of the valid options):

I.E.:
1. Punchwood
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Cathalea
4. Zak6858

Matrix added

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	0	0	0
Punchwood	1	-	1	1
Cathalea	1	0	-	0
Re-Open Nominations	1	0	1	-

Provisionally, I am counting it. It should be easy to tell if it affects the result.

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	4	5
Punchwood	12	-	10	9
Cathalea	10	4	-	5
Re-Open Nominations	9	5	9	-

Editing vote:

Punch wood
Cathalea
RoN

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	4	5
Punchwood	13	-	11	10
Cathalea	11	4	-	6
Re-Open Nominations	10	5	9	-

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Punchwood
2. Zak6858
3. Cathalea
3. Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	5	6
Punchwood	14	-	12	11
Cathalea	11	4	-	7
Re-Open Nominations	10	5	9	-

Punchwood
Re-Open Nominations
Cathalea

Guys please stop putting me on the ballot as I dropped out.

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	5	6
Punchwood	15	-	13	12
Cathalea	12	4	-	7
Re-Open Nominations	11	5	10	-

Re-Open Nominations.

This ballot cannot legally be counted as it does not rank multiple options: it expresses no preference between Punchwood or Cathalea, so I cannot even surmise a full ranking as I did for Omega.

Punchwood
RON

This ballot is also questionable. It does not explicitly list all options. The only way to interpret it unambiguously is if one assumes that Zak6858 is an invalid option due to their posted withdrawal from the race (and that the omitted option, Cathalea, is ranked last of the valid options):

I.E.:
1. Punchwood
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Cathalea
4. Zak6858

Provisionally, I am counting it. It should be easy to tell if it affects the result.

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	5	6
Punchwood	16	-	14	13
Cathalea	13	4	-	7
Re-Open Nominations	12	5	11	-

Punchwood
Re-Open Nominations

This ballot is questionable. It is the third like it. It does not explicitly list all options. The only way to interpret it unambiguously is if one assumes that Zak6858 is an invalid option due to their posted withdrawal from the race (and that the omitted option, Cathalea, is ranked last of the valid options):

I.E.:
1. Punchwood
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Cathalea
4. Zak6858

Provisionally, I am counting it. It should be easy to tell if it affects the result.

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	2	5	6
Punchwood	17	-	15	14
Cathalea	14	4	-	7
Re-Open Nominations	13	5	12	-

Minister of Regional Affairs Ballot
1. Re-Open Nominations
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Punchwood

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	3	5	6
Punchwood	17	-	15	14
Cathalea	15	5	-	7
Re-Open Nominations	14	6	13	-

Punchwood
Cathalea
RON

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	3	5	6
Punchwood	18	-	16	15
Cathalea	16	5	-	8
Re-Open Nominations	15	6	13	-

In random order, styled in my example style (changing "and" to "&" and abbreviations to full names), the following votes for Minister of Regional Affairs were received privately:

1. Punchwood
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	3	5	7
Punchwood	19	-	17	16
Cathalea	17	5	-	9
Re-Open Nominations	15	6	13	-

1. Punchwood
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	3	5	8
Punchwood	20	-	18	17
Cathalea	18	5	-	10
Re-Open Nominations	15	6	13	-

1. Cathalea
2. Punchwood
3. Re-Open Nominations
4. Zak6858

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	3	5	8
Punchwood	21	-	18	18
Cathalea	19	6	-	11
Re-Open Nominations	16	6	13	-

1. Cathalea
2. Punchwood
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	3	5	9
Punchwood	22	-	18	19
Cathalea	20	7	-	12
Re-Open Nominations	16	6	13	-

1. Zak6858
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Punchwood
4. Cathalea

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	4	6	10
Punchwood	22	-	19	19
Cathalea	20	7	-	12
Re-Open Nominations	16	7	14	-

1. Punchwood
2. Re-Open Nominations
3. Cathalea
4. Zak6858

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	4	6	10
Punchwood	23	-	20	20
Cathalea	21	7	-	12
Re-Open Nominations	17	7	15	-

1. Punchwood
2. Cathalea
3. Zak6858
4. Re-Open Nominations

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	4	6	11
Punchwood	24	-	21	21
Cathalea	22	7	-	13
Re-Open Nominations	17	7	15	-

In other words, Punchwood surpasses Cathalea in support 21 to 7; Zak6858 (if they are considered an option), 24 to 4, and Re-Open Nominations 21 to 7. Punchwood is therefore elected Minister of Regional Affairs.

Without Questionable Ballots

The three aforementioned questionable ballots add up to:

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	0	0	0
Punchwood	3	-	3	3
Cathalea	3	0	-	0
Re-Open Nominations	3	0	3	-

With them taken out, the totals are:

	Zak6858	Punchwood	Cathalea	Re-Open Nominations
Zak6858	-	4	6	11
Punchwood	21	-	18	18
Cathalea	19	7	-	13
Re-Open Nominations	14	7	12	-

In other words, Punchwood surpasses Cathalea in support 18 to 7; Zak6858 (if they are considered an option), 21 to 4, and Re-Open Nominations 18 to 7. Punchwood is therefore nevertheless elected Minister of Regional Affairs.

[Image: HuoZhaoDao.png]

Reply